Have a question? Call us.
438-255-8848Call
438-255-8848Call

Selling Your Car

Tired of Lowball Offers on Marketplace? Here’s What to Say

By the Car Buyers Montreal team

10+ years of experience in the automotive industry.

A few replies you can actually use, without spending your evening arguing about the price.

October 6, 2026

You put the car on Marketplace and the first message offers half your asking price. The next one just says, “Lowest?” It gets old quickly. When you’re getting lowball offers on your car, a clear price and a short reply go further than spending the evening defending every dollar.

Quick answer: Do not let the first low offer set your car’s value. Check comparable vehicles and get another purchase offer. Decide what you would accept, then reply briefly to specific proposals. Repeated, informed feedback may justify reviewing your price; abusive messages or offers made without reading the ad do not deserve your evening.

What price would you seriously consider?

Keep three numbers separate: your advertised price, the amount you would seriously consider and what another buyer would pay you. Base them on comparable vehicles and actual offers, not just what you recently spent on repairs.

New brakes are worth mentioning. They don’t automatically add the entire invoice to its market value. Keep the receipts, but price the whole car. The buyer isn’t paying your repair bills back.

How do you reply without an argument?

For a vague “lowest price?” message, try: “The asking price reflects the mileage and condition listed. If you have a specific offer after reviewing those details, send it over.”

For a low but polite offer: “Thanks. I’m not prepared to sell at that amount. I could consider $X, subject to agreeing on the payment and transfer arrangements.” Use a number you actually mean.

For an offer based on a claimed problem: “What condition issue are you allowing for? If you have an inspection finding, I’m happy to review it.” That separates useful information from a negotiating tactic.

When does buyer feedback justify a price change?

One unreasonable offer says little. Several informed buyers raising the same concern may tell you something about the car or your listing. Review the evidence before changing the price.

Don’t invent competing offers or hide known problems to gain leverage. Keep the conversation factual. You can stop responding to abusive messages and use the platform’s reporting tools where appropriate.

What other offer can you compare?

You’ve got better things to do than argue with every person in your inbox. Decide which offers deserve a reply and leave the rest.

How would this work in practice?

Illustrative example, in CAD: you advertise at $12,500, have a written direct offer of $11,000 and receive a private offer of $11,400. If accepting the private offer involves $150 in agreed extra expenses, the cash difference is $250. Compare payment, inspection and timing conditions before deciding whether that difference works for you.

What makes a Montreal price comparison useful?

Compare cars in the Montreal area with similar mileage, trim, condition and included winter equipment. Be explicit about whether the asking price includes a second wheel set. For a private Quebec sale, keep the buyer’s registration and QST budget separate from your agreed sale price; confirm the transfer arrangements before reserving an appointment.

Frequently asked questions

Should I write my lowest price in the ad?

Choose an asking price you can support. Decide privately what you would accept, and make sure any revised offer has clear payment and transfer conditions.

Is a low offer proof that my price is wrong?

One message is weak evidence. Several knowledgeable buyers pointing to the same mileage or condition issue deserve a closer look.

Can new brakes justify adding the invoice to my price?

They are useful maintenance information, but buyers assess the whole car. The repair bill is not automatically added dollar for dollar.

How should I handle abusive messages?

Stop engaging and use the platform’s blocking or reporting tools where appropriate. Keep your time for buyers asking specific questions.

Want an offer for your car?

Get a direct purchase offer as a comparison point. It can help you decide which private offers are worth answering. Request your car offer.

Related guides