Car Value
Another Repair Bill. Should You Sell the Car or Scrap It?
By the Car Buyers Montreal team
10+ years of experience in the automotive industry.
Compare a buyer’s offer with a recycler’s quote before deciding your old car has had its last winter.
The car’s got rust, the kilometres are climbing and your garage has just called with another estimate. Do you put more money into it, sell it or call a recycler? Before deciding to sell or scrap your car in Montreal, get a clear picture of its condition and a couple of real numbers.
Quick answer: Get a purchase offer for the car as it stands and a recycler’s quote before deciding. Compare what you keep after towing, pickup charges and other agreed costs. Describe known faults accurately. Selling for continued use and permanently discarding a vehicle involve different steps, so confirm which transaction you are authorizing.
What condition is the car actually in?
Write down the mileage, whether it starts and moves, known mechanical problems, visible rust and accident history. Add any professional diagnosis you have. “Needs a little work” is less useful than explaining that the car starts but can’t be driven because of a diagnosed brake problem.
Don’t crawl under an unsupported vehicle to take photos. A qualified shop can assess structural concerns that a driveway picture won’t resolve.
How do you compare a buyer with a recycler?
Ask a buyer whether they would purchase the car in its present condition. Separately, ask a recycler for a quote that identifies pickup charges, deductions and the documents required. Confirm who is collecting it and what happens to the registration.
Compare the amount you would keep after agreed costs. A higher headline quote may be less attractive if you must arrange towing or the amount changes when the truck arrives.
Is another repair worth the cost?
The money you’ve already spent is gone. The decision now is whether another expense creates enough benefit to be worthwhile. If a repair is needed for safe driving, that’s a safety decision; if it’s only intended to raise the selling price, ask what it would actually add.
Our repair-before-selling guide explains how to compare the cost with a realistic change in the offer.
Are you selling the vehicle or permanently discarding it?
A vehicle sold for continued use and one permanently discarded are different situations. Read the SAAQ’s vehicle-discarding instructions before authorizing that step. Keep collection and transaction records.
How would this work in practice?
Illustrative example, in CAD: a buyer offers $1,100 but requires $250 transport that you would pay. A recycler quotes $800 including collection. Your proceeds would be $850 versus $800, a $50 difference. Confirm that both quotes cover the same vehicle condition and that neither has further deductions.
What should your Montreal recycling quote include?
Ask whether towing from your Montreal, Laval or South Shore location is included and whether the quoted amount changes if the car does not start. Compare that net amount with a purchase offer in its present condition. Confirm the applicable Quebec registration or disposal steps before releasing the car, and retain the pickup receipt.
Frequently asked questions
Should I repair a non-running car first?
Get a diagnosis and compare the repair cost with an actual change in the purchase offer. Do not assume a repair adds its full cost to the selling price.
Can I drive it to the buyer?
Only if it can legally and safely be driven. A suspected brake, steering or structural problem needs professional assessment; arrange suitable transport where necessary.
What should a recycler’s quote include?
Ask for the amount payable, collection arrangements, possible deductions and documents required. Confirm whether the vehicle will be permanently discarded.
Does Car Buyers Montreal buy every old car?
No purchase is promised for every vehicle. Send the condition, kilometres and location so we can discuss whether a purchase is possible.
Want an offer for your car?
Send the car’s details and explain whether it starts and moves. Compare a purchase offer with a recycler’s complete quote before deciding. Request your car offer.